Skip to content
Knobs · The AoA podcast

Knobs Podcast S02 E02: Not All EQ Is Created Equal

S02E02 42 Min

EQ is usually the first processor anyone learns, and the one most people assume they have figured out. In this episode Simon Moro and Terry Hart go back to first principles and ask a more useful question:

When you reach for an EQ, what are you actually doing to the sound, and is it the sound you think you are fixing?

Drawing on years of mixing and mastering, from SSL consoles to mastering rooms to Pro Tools sessions, the conversation moves from the history of equalisation to the habits that separate a confident move from a guess.

What EQ Actually Is

Like a lot of studio tools, EQ was built for something else. Simon traces it to telecommunications, where high frequencies lost energy over kilometres of copper cable and equalisation boosted them back so the output matched the input.

Stripped back, EQ is frequency-dependent gain: a fader, but for one part of the spectrum. Terry’s warning is that this immediacy is also the trap.

“Because you can hear it, you get trapped into the idea of thinking you understand it.”

A compressor can be hard to hear at first. An EQ makes things brighter in a second, and brighter feels like better, even when it isn’t.

Cut Narrow, Boost Wide

Both hosts start in the same place: before reaching for any tool, recognise that you want to change the sound, then decide what, in what order, and with what. A consistent tonal problem is a job for EQ. An intermittent one might be a job for dynamic EQ or something else entirely.

The rules of thumb:

There is no such thing as a perfect notch. Cut 3k savagely and you get a lump either side of it, which is why people who keep notching keep hearing more problems. Used deliberately, a notch is perfect for a floor tom ringing at one frequency through every mic.

Are You EQing the Song or the Room?

This links back to a recent episode on translation. If your room is not accurate, every EQ move is made blind, and translation suffers whether you cut or boost.

“If you’re not working in a flat environment, are you really equalising?”

Simon’s tip: do 70% less of a cut or boost. If you boost 80 Hz on the kick by 10 dB because your room is swallowing it, the mix will be 10 dB too heavy everywhere else. Boost 3 dB and you are far less wrong. Terry still dials his decisions back to half, and to a quarter when mastering. Simon adds that in mastering, half a dB on the right EQ can matter a great deal.

Once Simon had a good room and good monitors, he found 3 dB was about as hot as his boosts got. A 10 dB boost now usually means a source genuinely missing its top end, confirmed on a spectrum analyser.

You Can’t Boost What Isn’t There

If the frequencies are not in the recording, turning them up just gives you hiss. Terry often goes the other way: cut enough low end and the sound gets brighter by comparison. One of his favourite tricks for a lead guitar that won’t cut through is a hard high cut, way down around 2 to 4k, and suddenly it is clear as a bell, as if the ear fills in the missing top.

Simon frames this as frequency arranging, voicing the spectrum the way you would voice chords. When something needs to be fatter and the frequencies simply aren’t there, add harmonics first with saturation or harmonic processing, then shape with EQ.

Then the line the whole episode turns on: not all gain is created equal, and not all EQ is the same. Terry shares a trick from mastering engineer Scott Hull: boost 2k with an API because it suits guitars, then pull it back to neutral with a clean digital EQ. On an analyser nothing has changed. Mute both and the guitars disappear. The same works with a Pultec or other tube EQ, whose transformers add colour on the way through. In mastering, where every dB of boost costs headroom, that matters.

Before or After the Compressor?

The contentious one. The answer is both, and it depends on the outcome you want. Terry’s tiny mastering moves are often really about the compressor: a quarter of a dB going in can change how the rhythm feels. Simon’s usual sequence is corrective work and filtering first, then compression, then tone shaping again. Another variation: a broad boost with the centre pulled down slightly, giving a flat top instead of a bell.

Filters, Masking and Moving Parts

Terry once challenged himself to mix with only high and low pass filters, and still loves the result. Simon admits to an early phase of filtering the lows out of everything except kick and bass, because his monitoring wasn’t right. Now it is intentional:

Cutter or Booster?

Terry finds most mix engineers lean one way. Simon is more aggressive with cuts, because masking is the job, and boosts little beyond air on vocals, sometimes letting multiband compression or a Michael Brauer style multi-compressor vocal do the tonal work. Terry is mostly subtractive too, and it explained why he never clicked with SSL G series desks, which he found suit boost-first mixers, while he loved the more surgical E and the K.

Simon notes that “musical” EQ is mostly about curves that suit balancing music. Terry’s advice for anyone starting out: musical EQs are safe, surgical EQs can do real damage.

Dynamic EQ

Terry points out that every compressor is already a dynamic EQ, tilting the tone however gently you touch it. A true dynamic EQ is a curve you choose, applied only when a frequency crosses a threshold, with attack and release. Unlike multiband compression, you set the exact shape. Uses that come up:

For masking Simon prefers Trackspacer, which follows the bass as it moves. Terry’s alternative: mute things until it sounds good again.

Final Thoughts

The closing advice is about listening. Your ears adapt fast, so anchor a reference: listen to the hi-hat, flip the EQ in and out, did it change? Then the kick, then the guitar attack. Simon admits he rarely does this now, thanks to experience and a good room, but it is where you go back to when stumped.

“Stop working in isolation.”

Mixing is putting things together, so EQ in context, not in solo. Treat every boost as gain you are spending, and choose carefully where it comes from.

Make records, not debt
Want to learn this properly?
Explore the course